Americans (46%) Have Been Porch Pirate Victims

Dated: December 10 2025

Views: 66

46% of Americans Have Been Porch Pirate Victims

This year, 95% of holiday shoppers will do at least some of their shopping online, making them potential targets for porch pirates looking to steal packages, according to a survey by Insurify. 

As shoppers increasingly rely on online shopping, package theft has also increased. In fact, nearly half (46%) of those surveyed reported experiencing package theft before, and 32% said it occurs multiple times each year. 

Understandably, package theft increases around the holidays, and about 49% of Cyber Monday shoppers said they’ve had a package stolen. Additionally, data shows that online searches about stolen packages consistently spike every December.  

So, how much are Americans losing from porch pirate crimes? The majority (82%) reported having lost out on a delivery worth $100 or more, and 20% stated that the most valuable package they had stolen was worth more than $500. 

When asked what their biggest holiday home concerns were, package theft topped the list: 

  1. Package theft (28%) 
  2. Break-ins while traveling (26%) 
  3. Burst pipes or water damage from freezing (22%) 
  4. Fires from decorations, candles or cooking (10%) 
  5. Slips or injuries on their property (e.g., guests, delivery drivers) (16%) 

Here are some ways to prevent porch pirates from striking this holiday season: 

  • Track packages closely to know when they’ll be delivered. Retrieve them as soon as possible to decrease thieves’ window of opportunity. 
  • Get packages delivered to secure pickup locations, like lockers, lockboxes, delivery hubs, etc. A trusted neighbor, family member or friend can also be helpful.  
  • Install a video doorbell. Porch pirates who know they’re being recorded may be less inclined to steal, and video proof of the crime can be beneficial.  
Blog author image

Paul Gornall

Personal Service With A Difference You probably know how important it is to find the right real estate agent when you are focusing on a financial investment as substantial and as personal as your home....

Latest Blog Posts

Pa. Housing Market Holds Steady in August

Pa. Housing Market Holds Steady in AugustBy David DeanSeptember 22, 20262 min.Pennsylvania’s housing market held steady in August, as home sales, listings and median home price remained

Read More

9 Home Maintenance Tasks You Can Do Today

9 Home Maintenance Tasks You Can Do This WeekendBy Hope Walborn August 26, 2026 3 min.Summers are busy, but home maintenance doesn’t need to take a backseat. Before

Read More

Deal Breakers for Homebuyers: What Turns Buyers Away

Homebuying Deal Breakers: What Turns Buyers AwayBy Hope Walborn August 18, 2026 2 min.When looking for a home to buy, some things can make or break the decision to pursue a listing.

Read More

Over 90% of Homeowners Planning to DIY This Year

94% of Homeowners Planning to DIY This YearBy Hope Walborn July 23, 2026 2 min.12sharesThe majority (94%) of homeowners surveyed by 2-10 Home Buyers Warranty said they had DIY projects

Read More